Monday, October 19, 2026

Egyptian Mathematics

 The Tomb of Menna painting appears to have many mathematical elements. The overall layout appears to have two different sections. The upper half depicts a range of farming activities, and the lower half contains a few different themes and objects. In the upper half, we see tow men holding a long piece of rope taut, a woman balancing a basket on her head, a woman carrying a pronged stick, and what looks to be a couple of "rulers" carried by three people.  By "rulers", I mean about a foot long (relative to arm length) rectangular tool with markings on them. The bottom half contains a light weight chariot, a row of scribes writing on the ruler-type objects, which may in fact be paper notes of sorts, and a green rectangular frame containing a person with a pronged stick and some symbols. It almost looks like the green frame is a collection pipes and someone is filling up a vessel near the base. My primary questions are: Why were the people carrying the rope in the upper half, what are the little rectangular objects people are carrying, and what does the scripture represent mean in the back of the green frame?

The article "Surveying in Egypt", confirms several of my suspisicions about what's depicted in the Tomb of Menna painting. Long distances were measured using a rope which had knots at regular intervals, and different people had roles. Two carried coils of rope in their arms, while the others assist in carrying the rope. The article does not discuss the lower half, but I wonder if perhaps they're making notes for building plans, and the division represents the design/ administrative side compared to the field work of surveying.

The authors discussion on the system of measurement was interesting, The cubit is a really natural measurement, in the same way that a foot is. Using a base measurement and then taking multiples of that to form conventional distances would have been one of the most important technological revolutions for that society.  Using the cubit as a base, the development of the ramen also standardizes many possible trigonometric measurements, but using distances rather than angles. A direct application of the remen is to allow areas of land to be halved, or doubled, while preserving proportion.

One final thought is that I find it fascinating how their ways of measurement are used in their daily lives to do different tasks, but it's importance tends all the way up the their religion, for example the orientation of the pyramids. 

Monday, September 28, 2026

Market Vendor Puzzle for Sep 28

 

A more organized summary. Reading the comments as you work down the columns
is helpful!

So the set of number is {1,3,9, 27}. Powers of 3. Curious.



Solving it for the first time

Minimal set of number to sum to each of {1,..,31}?

A moments thought shows that we certainly need 1, 2 and 4. Then we can get up to 7, so we need 8.
Using the set {1,2,4,8} we can get up to 15, which means we need 16. Thus, selecting from {1,2,4,8,16} we can sum to every number in the set {1,2,...,30,31}.  Now powers of 2... strange.

A useful way to approach the problem:

Thinking of this problem recursively is best. Suppose we can sum to all the number less than say n. If we add n to the collection, we get up to 2n-1. 

Extending... Why powers of 3? Why powers of 2?

The first thing to know is that in ternary, 40 is written as 1111=1000+100+10+1, which represent individual weights. In binary 31 is written as 11111 = 10 000 + 1000 + 100 + 10 + 1, which also represent individual weights. In a high school math class, this would be a great way to introduce working in different bases, and what it really means, instead of just providing a key to convert between the two.

Teaching Recursion

This is also an opportunity to teach an intro to recursion. Let's derive the sequence of numbers for the original problem:

Let tn be the sequence of weights needed. In our sequence: starting with 1,3, we get the next number with the following logic: 2(1+3) +1 = 9. Let Sn represent the sum of the previous numbers in the sequence. Then we have
t_{n} = 2S_{n-1} +1
t_{n+1} = 2(t_n + S_{n-1})+1

Solving the system by taking t_{n+1}-t_n gives t_{n+1}=3t_n.

This is the recurrence relation for t(n) = 3^n for n=0,1,2,... .





Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Reading for Sep 23

 It's an interesting exercise to try to imagine how general mathematical statements could be made without the use of algebra. I suppose the Babylonians use algebra implicitly in their statements, but discuss the relationships between quantities. Moreover, it almost feels like dependencies and relationships in Babylonian mathematics are almost parametrized by a time variable, t. When we write a mathematical statement with algebra, while it still reads left to right, it its on the page as one singular statement. Babylonian statements about math tend to read more like algorithms, or a series of steps (like example 4.8 in the handout).

I think that math is about whatever you decide to make it about. Without wanting to get too philosophical about it, statements about logic "exist" in a sense, and they'll be true or false. Our use of such statements and our exploration of mathematics is really what we make of it. For the Babylonians, it seems as though it's supposed to be practical. Perhaps in due time they would have developed further tools to explore the concepts of algebra and abstraction, as there was clearly an academic inclination study such topics.

One area of mathematics I think would be interesting to discuss without the use of algebra would be graph theory. If instead of using algebra, we simply discussed the relationships that different vertices have with each other, we could perhaps open up the world of graph theory to students who have yet to develop the algebra skills necessary to study the subject. For example, as is suggested in the name, the handshaking lemma can be explained not only with a simple drawing on the board, but by telling a story about how people might shake hands at a party.


Monday, September 21, 2026

Reading for Sep 21

 I thought the different explanations for why babylonians used based 60 to be super interesting. The argument for the relationship between the cyclic nature of day and night represents by a circle, and the development of longitudes and latitudes with the use of 360 degrees to move around the earth was novel to me. I thought the use of the 12 starts which signify total darkness during the equinox form a natural basis for the development of the hour. In which case we have 24 hours in the day. Where I wish the article expanded more, was the integration of the minute and the hour, because this necessarily forces the timespan of a second to consist of 3600 repetitions in an hour. 

The use of 360 degrees, and 60 seconds in an hour has certainly played a huge role in my development and understanding of geometry. Equilateral triangles, trigonometric identities, time keeping, and even the initial development of modular arithmetic was all made easier by the fact that 60 has many factors. Rational numbers, terminating decimals and easy-to-remember roots played a key role in my understanding of geometry. Moreover, there always seemed to be a natural progression from 360 degrees in as circle to 365 days a year - a fact which provides a sense of continuity from the second up to the year.


3 of the 18 stars represent dusk, 3 for dawn,
leaving 12 for night 



Tuesday, September 15, 2026

Reading for Sep 16

 The classic 'Eurocentric' trajectory assumes that the basis of modern science is strictly European, and neglects that many other cultures had their own scientific developments independent of western colonialism. An early fact I found really interesting was that to Aristotle, Egypt was the centre for mathematics. Reflecting on this, it follows that Egypt, Mesopotamia, and other civilizations of the area had their own development of mathematics. How could, as an obvious example, it be that the pyramids were made? Or, for that matter, how could any of the complex feats of building, architecture and engineering without a solid understanding of mathematics. I also found the alternative trajectories for the dark ages fascinating. In my view, the renaissance was about europe's rediscovery of what was lost from the greek times. Unfortunately none of the credit was given to China, India, and the Hellenistic world.

This reading also piqued my curiosity in Mayan astronomy, and that their knowledge with rudimentary tools surpassed europe's at the time. Integrating mathematics and astronomy would be something I'm very keen to continue to explore. In particular, I'd like to explore if there are recorded examples of indigenous astronomy, and how the study of geometry or gravity can be connected to cultural learnings.

Egyptian Mathematics

 The Tomb of Menna painting appears to have many mathematical elements. The overall layout appears to have two different sections. The upper...